Guntherus de Thuringia

Bishop Rob Mutsaerts says ‘The missing words in the Synod are repentance and conversion’

EXCLUSIVE INTERVIEW [advaticanum] Bishop Rob Mutsaerts has served as the Auxiliary Bishop of the Diocese of ’s-Hertogenbosch since 2010. His ministry has been typified by a confidence in proclaiming the truth, notably through his criticism of the 2019 Amazon Synod and his concerns over the lack of evangelical wisdom behind Traditionis Custodes.

He has also been a forceful voice against the tides of Dutch secularism in a country that has experienced some of the more pernicious elements of the trend. In the Netherlands, the lives of newborns and children under 12 can be deliberately ended without an affirmative request from the child under strictly defined circumstances, while euthanasia can be administered to those aged 12 and over in cases of psychiatric suffering. Almost 60 per cent of the country reports no religious affiliation, while Islam is the fastest-growing major religion, with more than twice as many 15–17-year-olds identifying as Muslim (14.2 per cent) as Catholic (6.9 per cent). Against this backdrop, His Grace has worked tirelessly, writing numerous spiritual works and encouraging conversions, work that is bearing fruit in a country that saw a 40 per cent increase in adult baptisms in 2024.

In this exclusive interview, Bishop Mutsaerts shares with AdVaticanum his reflections on a recent open letter he wrote to Pope Leo XIV, his views on the synodal process and how he sees the Church in the Netherlands.

AV: In your recent open letter to Pope Leo XIV, you write that judging the synodal process by its own internal metrics (listening, participation, documents) can produce a positive narrative, but that the real tests are stronger faith, clearer proclamation of Christ, deeper Catholic identity, more conversions, higher Sunday Mass attendance, etc. Could you walk us through how you arrived at that list of criteria?

+RM: The final canon of the Code of Canon Law ends with the famous principle that “the salvation of souls … must always be the supreme law in the Church” (salus animarum … suprema semper lex esse debet, can. 1752). If one evaluates the synodal process, the decisive question is not whether ...

>>EXCLUSIVE INTERVIEW Bishop Rob Mutsaerts says …
504

Man is created for God. He is wounded by sin. Christ died for him. Grace is real. Mortal sin is real. Judgment is real. Heaven is real. Hell is real. Forgiveness is real. The Eucharist is really Christ. Confession really reconciles the sinner with God. Once these things are believed intensely, pastoral priorities change immediately. One becomes intensely interested in confessions, baptisms, conversions, Catholic marriages, Mass attendance, Eucharistic devotion, catechesis, family prayer, and holiness. A Church concerned with salvation inevitably wants to know whether more people are going to confession. A bureaucracy concerned with process wants to know whether more people participated in the consultation.
There is a wonderfully simple biblical criterion: “By their fruits you shall know them.” Apply it without malice and without ideological prejudice. Above all: are people willing to become saints? This question is considerably more important than asking whether people experienced the synodal process positively.

165