Alonzo Mann Deposition to Harry Scott, Pinkerton Detective, May 1913, Atlanta, Georgia
My name is Alonzo McClendon Mann. I am 83 years old, born near Memphis, Tennessee, on August 8, 1898, later raised in Atlanta. In 1913, at age fourteen, I was office boy for Leo M. Frank at the National Pencil Company when Mary Phagan, a girl my age, was murdered and Frank was convicted. I testified at his trial but did not reveal everything I knew, because I was not asked and I was frightened. I now state that Leo Frank did not kill Mary Phagan; Jim Conley, the janitor and main witness against Frank, lied under oath and was the real killer.
On Confederate Memorial Day, 1913, I arrived at the factory about 8 a.m. and saw Conley drunk under the stairwell asking me for money. I left shortly before noon to meet my mother, saw Conley still there, then returned in less than half an hour. When I came back in the front door, I saw Conley near the trapdoor to the basement holding a small girl’s limp body in his arms, later known to be Mary Phagan. She appeared unconscious or dead; I saw no blood. Conley turned, threatened, “If you ever mention this, I’ll kill you.” Terrified, I fled home.
I told my mother, and later my father, what I had seen and of Conley’s threat. They insisted I remain silent to protect me and the family. When questioned by detectives and later on the witness stand, I described only events before leaving to meet my mother and did not reveal my return or Conley with the body. I have lived for decades knowing my silence helped allow an innocent man to be convicted and later lynched.
Leo Frank was a proper, decent manager, falsely accused amid lies and prejudice. I suffer from a heart condition and wear a pacemaker, and I now make this statement to clear the record and warn that courts and juries can make terrible mistakes. All I have said is the truth, and I place it on the record before God and history.
You can check out the 2025 newly revised book of Mary Phagan and Leo Frank Case from the 1987 older version by Mary Phagan-Kean, Now Available on Amazon Books.
WEBSITE: Little Mary Phagan, Leo Frank, Jim Conley, 1913 …